Content provided by PAR, Inc.
Across the United States and all over the world, law enforcement agencies are grappling with a recruitment and retention crisis that shows no signs of slowing. According to the International Association of Chiefs of Police (IACP), 78% of agencies report having difficulty recruiting qualified candidates, and 65% say they’re struggling to retain officers already on the force. The causes are multifaceted, ranging from shifting public perceptions and increased scrutiny to rising job stress and a shrinking pool of applicants willing to take on the demands of modern policing.
In response, agencies are rethinking their hiring strategies, placing greater emphasis on tools that can help identify candidates who are not only capable but also psychologically prepared for the realities of the job. Psychological assessments have long been a part of the pre-employment process, but their strategic value is now being reexamined through a sharper lens.
One such tool gaining renewed attention is the Personality Assessment Inventory (PAI). Originally developed for clinical use, the PAI has been widely adopted in public safety settings for its ability to assess psychological readiness in high-stakes roles.
The challenge: Enhancing safety and performance through early risk detection
Modern policing requires more than physical readiness and technical skill – it demands psychological resilience, emotional regulation and sound judgment under pressure. Officers are routinely placed in high-stakes situations that test their ability to remain calm, think critically and engage with the public in a fair and empathetic manner. Yet, many traditional recruitment processes fall short in evaluating these essential traits.
According to the IACP’s 2024 Recruitment and Retention Survey, 85% of agencies report that the psychological demands of the job are a growing concern, particularly as younger recruits enter the field with different expectations and stress thresholds. The PAI addresses this gap by offering a nuanced profile of a candidate’s psychological functioning. It delivers a standardized, evidence-based approach to identifying candidates who are psychologically equipped to handle the realities that officers must face.
The PAI: A scientifically validated tool for high-stakes roles
With more and more law enforcement agencies seeking to modernize their recruitment strategies, a spotlight has been placed on the importance of psychological screening. The PAI continues to stand out as a reliable tool for this assessment process, providing key insights that help to prevent issues further down the line.
Developed by Dr. Leslie Morey, the PAI is a self-administered, objective inventory that assesses a broad range of clinical variables relevant to mental health and personality functioning. It has been extensively validated across diverse populations and is widely used in forensic, clinical and public safety settings. For law enforcement, this means the tool is not only credible but also tailored to the unique psychological demands of the profession.
The PAI’s relevance to policing is underscored by its ability to measure traits that directly impact job performance and safety – such as impulse control, alcohol and drug use, aggression, stress tolerance and interpersonal functioning. These are not abstract qualities; they are critical indicators of how an officer might respond under pressure, interact with the public or manage the emotional toll of the job.
For example, elevated scores in aggression or poor impulse control may signal a higher risk for problematic behavior in the field, while low stress tolerance could indicate vulnerability to burnout or poor crisis response. By identifying these patterns early, agencies can make more informed hiring decisions and prioritize candidates who are better psychologically equipped.
This alignment between assessment and occupational reality is especially important as agencies face increasing scrutiny over officer conduct and community relations. A 2024 report from the Police Executive Research Forum (PERF) emphasizes the need for “emotionally intelligent policing,” noting that officers who demonstrate empathy, self-awareness and emotional regulation are more likely to de-escalate tense situations and build public trust.
Seamless integration into existing hiring protocols
The PAI’s standardized, evidence-based format that reduces bias and subjectivity makes it a valuable addition to any agency’s recruitment toolkit. It doesn’t replace interviews or background checks – it adds a critical layer of insight that helps ensure new hires are not only capable, but also psychologically prepared for the realities of the role.
For agencies already conducting clinical interviews or fitness-for-duty assessments, the PAI requires minimal operational change. It can be administered efficiently, interpreted by licensed psychologists and used alongside other tools without disrupting established workflows.
This ease of integration is especially valuable for departments managing high applicant volumes or operating with limited resources. The PAI adds consistency and depth to candidate evaluations, helping agencies make more informed, defensible hiring decisions.
By identifying psychological risk factors early and supporting fair, data-driven selection, the PAI helps reduce costly turnover and mitigate the risk of hiring mismatches – two of the most pressing concerns in today’s recruitment landscape. In doing so, it offers agencies a scalable solution to ease the strain of staffing shortages while reinforcing long-term workforce stability.
Its structured format also supports documentation and transparency, both of which are critical in today’s hiring environment, where fairness and accountability are under increasing scrutiny. By embedding the PAI into existing protocols, agencies can strengthen both the rigor and equity of their recruitment practices without adding unnecessary complexity.