Ex-Sheriff gets 10 years in bizarre NM road rage case

Rodella, who was in plain clothes at the time, said Tafoya was a reckless driver whom he was trying to stop in the interest of public safety

By Russell Contreras
Associated Press

ALBUQUERQUE, N.M. — A federal judge on Wednesday sentenced a former New Mexico sheriff to 10 years in prison for abusing a driver in a bizarre, off-duty traffic stop that prosecutors described as a fit of road rage.

Ex-Rio Arriba County Sheriff Thomas Rodella told the judge during the sentencing hearing that he did good deeds during his tenure, and the court received letters from community members who praised his service.

However, others wrote letters criticizing the former sheriff over allegations that he abused his office.

One letter compared Rodella to the Dallas Cowboys, U.S. District Judge James Browning said. Either you love him or you hate him, he said.

Defense attorneys sought to lessen Rodella's term over health concerns. But prosecutors argued Rodella created a dangerous situation the day he pulled over a motorist, and health concerns were an issue when he sought re-election.

"I hope this is part of your journey in life," Browning told Rodella during sentencing. "I hope you use this time."

The sentence, which includes three years of supervised release and a $200,000 fine, left Rodella's family and friends in tears. They consoled each other outside the courthouse and declined to answer reporters' questions.

Rodella was convicted of brandishing a firearm and deprivation of rights following a four-day trial in September.

He faced up to 17 years in prison over the March encounter.

According to prosecutors, Rodella pulled a gun on Michael Tafoya and struck him in the face with his badge because Tafoya cut him off in traffic.

Tafoya testified during the trial that he felt his life was in danger when Rodella chased him and pulled out his gun.

"I said, 'Please, don't kill me,'" Tafoya told jurors.

Rodella, who was in plain clothes at the time, said Tafoya was a reckless driver whom he was trying to stop in the interest of public safety.

Defense lawyer Robert Gorence twice tried to win a new trial but was unsuccessful. He has said Rodella plans to appeal.

U.S. Attorney Damon Martinez said he respected the judge's decision despite the reduced sentence. But he noted law officers need to keep the public's trust.

"When one of those officers crosses the line ... that person needs to be held accountable," Martinez said.

The sentencing likely ends Rodella's long, troubled career in politics and law enforcement.

Rodella was elected sheriff in 2010, despite having been ousted as a magistrate judge by the state Supreme Court two years earlier for misconduct. The court barred him from running again for judicial office.

Then-Gov. Bill Richardson appointed Rodella as a magistrate in 2005. But Rodella resigned a few months later amid criticism — and pressure from Richardson — for helping secure the release of a family friend who was jailed for drunken driving.

As a state police officer, Rodella was disciplined for marijuana use, improper use of a weapon, falsifying official reports, abusing sick leave and using his position for personal gain.

Last year, the FBI searched the sheriff's office in Espanola after media reports that Rodella's staff was accepting donations for a scholarship fund managed by Rodella, in lieu of prosecuting some traffic offenses. He was not charged in that case.

As an incumbent in the June primary, he lost the Democratic nomination for Rio Arriba County sheriff to James Lujan by 200 votes. Lujan was a deputy whom Rodella had fired.

FBI agents searched Rodella's home in the road rage case hours after he lost the election.

Copyright 2015 The Associated Press

Recommended for you

Copyright © 2022 Police1. All rights reserved.