Trending Topics

Coffee shop owner awarded $4M in lawsuit over thin blue line flag display, shop closure

The owner of Big City Coffee said she was forced to close after Boise State students raised objections to her support of the thin blue line flag

Thin blue line flag ban in Pa. township is unconstitutional, judge rules

Prohibiting the use of the thin blue line flag restricts the free speech of public employees under the First Amendment, U.S. District Judge Karen Marston decided.

AP Photo/Morry Gash, File

By Joanna Putman
Police1

BOISE, Idaho — A jury has ordered Boise State University to pay $4 million to the owner of Big City Coffee in a lawsuit stemming from the closure of the shop following student concerns over her pro-police views, the Idaho Statesman reported.

On Sept. 13, a jury sided with Sarah Fendley and awarded her $3 million for business losses, emotional distress, personal humiliation and reputational damage, according to the report. An additional $1 million in punitive damages was levied against former Boise State Vice President of Student Affairs Leslie Webb, who was named in the lawsuit.

The dispute began when Fendley’s campus shop closed in October 2020, just six weeks after opening. Fendley claimed she was forced out after students raised objections to her support of the “thin blue line” symbol, according to the report. The lawsuit centered on whether Boise State administrators retaliated against her for exercising her First Amendment rights by penalizing her for her pro-police stance.



Boise State’s attorney argued that Fendley terminated the contract herself, while Fendley’s legal team maintained the university’s actions drove her to close the shop. Fendley initially sought $10 million in damages.

Big City Coffee’s downtown Boise location also closed earlier this month, and Fendley announced she would be “taking a break” from the business, according to the report.

Trending
The first order aims to provide legal assistance to officers, enhance penalties for crimes committed against cops, increase pay and expand the size and security of prisons
In 2024, Seattle PD rolled out a package of incentives, including a $50,000 bonus for lateral recruits; the department has brought on 60 new officers in 2025
Two Logan County deputies were walking through a yard, issuing instructions for the man to show himself, when both were suddenly struck by gunfire
The Charlotte-Mecklenburg Police Department released an hour-long documentary about the incident, while the community gathered to hold a memorial stair climb