Trending Topics

Judge rules Okla. deputy’s warrantless ALPR search violated Fourth Amendment

The judge suppressed evidence in a case after finding the deputy began following the rental car for no reason other than its California plates

License Plate Cameras

A license plate reader is seen along a public road, Thursday, Oct. 16, 2025, in Houston.

AP Photo/David Goldman

TULSA, Okla. — A federal judge has ruled that a Tulsa County deputy violated the Fourth Amendment by searching license plate reader databases for a month of a woman’s travel history without a warrant, the Dallas Express reported.

On Oct. 1, U.S. District Judge Sara E. Hill granted a motion to suppress evidence in the case against Melisa Susan Kyle, who faced federal charges of possessing more than 500 grams of methamphetamine with intent to distribute.

| SPECIAL REPORT: Where is your agency losing time?

Hill wrote that Deputy Freddie Alaniz began following Kyle’s rental vehicle with “no apparent reason other than” its California license plate. Alaniz then queried Flock and VehicleManager, which returned more than 50 location records from multiple states covering an entire month, according to the ruling. He then stopped the vehicle.

The government argued that drivers have no reasonable expectation of privacy in license plates and movements visible on public roads. Hill disagreed, relying on Supreme Court precedent, including Carpenter v. United States, CBS 12 reported. She wrote that police cannot “use a vast network of cameras to indiscriminately collect vehicle data, then retrieve a detailed history of a person’s movements on demand without probable cause and a warrant.”

The judge found that Kyle had a reasonable expectation of privacy in “the whole of her physical movements.” She noted that such data can reveal sensitive information, including visits to medical providers, lawyers, fertility clinics, casinos or liquor stores.

The ruling does not bar all license plate reader use or individual camera scans, according to CBS 12. It addresses historical, multistate searches covering about a month.

Hill upheld the initial traffic stop. But she found that Alaniz lacked reasonable suspicion to extend it for a drug investigation.

Trending
Agencies from California to Calgary used social media to remind fans that real-world consequences don’t come with cheat codes
Chocolate milk, a drug dealer complaint line and a Microsoft Teams joke have helped Greensboro PD reach millions
The Massachusetts State Police dropped the drill instructor title as part of a broader overhaul that also includes expanded medical oversight and a new framework for stress training
Madison Officer Kiel Baitinger-Peterson acted reasonably in shooting Corey Ruiz after he allegedly wielded a knife and injured the officer, the Dane County District Attorney stated
Company News
The new interfaces automate firearm and incident data sharing from the RMS to ATF to accelerate investigations and bring police departments faster, more reliable intelligence

Police1 Staff comprises experienced writers, editors, and law enforcement professionals dedicated to delivering trusted, timely, and actionable information and resources for public safety. As the leading source for law enforcement news, resources, and training, Police1 is committed to supporting officers with expert advice, industry updates, and career development tools. From breaking news to in-depth analysis of critical topics, Police1 Staff provides the knowledge and insights you need to stay informed and ahead in the field of policing.

Interested in expert-driven resources delivered for free directly to your inbox? Subscribe for free to any our our Police1 newsletters.