Trending Topics

Judge dismisses Karen Read’s conspiracy claims against PD involved in homicide investigation

A judge ruled that Read’s lawsuit did not establish that the Canton PD took “proactive and intentional actions” to steer its investigation of the death of her boyfriend, Boston police Officer John O’Keefe, toward her

Karen Read Trial

Karen Read stands during her trial at Norfolk Superior Court, Thursday, June 12, 2025, in Dedham, Mass. (AP Photo/Charles Krupa, Pool)

Charles Krupa/AP

By Charlie McKenna
masslive.com

CANTON, Mass. — A judge dismissed Karen Read ’s conspiracy claim against the Canton Police Department, finding her lawsuit did not establish that the department took “proactive and intentional actions” to steer its investigation of the death of her boyfriend, Boston police Officer John O’Keefe, toward her.

But Judge Mark Gildea upheld the portion of Read’s suit that accused the department of negligence, denying the town’s motion to dismiss as to that claim.

Read filed the lawsuit in June, nearly a year after a jury acquitted her of charges connected with O’Keefe’s death. She accused the town, through its police department, of negligence in its hiring, training, supervision and retention of officers and in its enforcement of policies to safeguard evidence and prevent discrimination.

The suit also claimed that Canton Police conspired with Massachusetts State Police to improperly steer its investigation toward her, rather than the group of people inside the home O’Keefe’s body was found outside in January 2022.

To support her claims, Read’s complaint included shocking texts exchanged by two investigators — former State Police Trooper Michael Proctor and former Canton police Sgt. Sean Goode.

Gildea determined that Read’s conspiracy claim ran afoul of the Massachusetts Tort Claims Act, which largely protects public employers from being sued for intentional wrongdoing committed by one of its employees.

Read’s lawyers argued the claim was exempt from the law because it was the departments’ carelessness that led them to direct the investigation toward her, not a deliberate act.

“She contends that it is sufficient that the CPD shared an unlawful intent with the MSP, and that its negligent actions furthered that shared intent,” Gildea wrote. That argument “confuses the very nature of a conspiracy,” he said.

Instead, Read had to show an agreement between the two police departments to support a conspiracy claim. Even if her lawsuit suggests an implied agreement, Read still has to accuse Canton Police of “affirmative steps to encourage the achievement of the shared plan to direct the investigation towards her,” Gildea wrote.

“The nature of a civil conspiracy claim involves intentional acts. Therefore, the claim cannot be asserted against the Town,” Gildea’s order reads.

On the negligence claim, Gildea dismissed two arguments by the town: that Read’s suit came after the statute of limitations expired, and that she failed to properly give notice of the allegations she would include.

The town claimed the three-year statute of limitations should have started on Feb. 2, 2022 — the date of Read’s arraignment — arguing that is when she became aware of the harms laid out in her lawsuit. But Gildea noted that Read’s lawsuit says she did not become aware of much of the evidence underlying the department’s negligence until after acquittal.

The town’s second argument hinges on the “presentment letter” it received from Read in November 2025. Massachusetts law requires people to send such letters when they intend to sue a public employer. After sending one, a person must wait six months before filing a suit.

In Read’s case, Canton claimed the letter was untimely and failed to put it on notice of the “factual and legal bases” of her claims.

Gildea said he was “not persuaded by either argument.”

“The letter ... makes clear that the basis of the negligence claim is the Town’s actions with respect to its employees,” he wrote.

The ruling essentially leaves the lawsuit with one remaining claim.

Earlier this month, Read agreed to resolve her claims against the State Police after the agency said it would pay her $100,000 to settle the case — the highest amount she could receive under state law.

The lawsuit against the police departments is an extension of a suit Read filed last November against the individual investigators who worked on her case and witnesses who testified against her. She intended to bring the claims against the two police departments as part of that case, but had to pursue a separate action when the witnesses moved the lawsuit to federal court. The State Police can’t be sued in federal court.

The federal suit is still pending, as are two other lawsuits involving Read: a defamation suit brought by the witnesses and a wrongful death suit filed by O’Keefe’s family.

Trending
Southside ISD Police Officer Christina Lozano, 47, was described as a “dedicated and valued employee,” as well as a “loving mother and grandmother”
The suspect was tracked down and arrested after appearing to deliberately drive toward and hit an officer, according to the Medway Police Department
The man walked forward as the Metro Nashville Police detective backed away, approaching within feet of him before officers fired the fatal shots
Around 70 protesters will receive approximately $26,000 each from the city of Charlotte after settling a lawsuit over the department’s use of a now-banned “kettling” technique

©2026 Advance Local Media LLC. Visit masslive.com. Distributed by Tribune Content Agency, LLC.

Company News
Marine Corps veteran and former Babel Street Chief Operating Officer, who helped build a national security technology company from early-stage startup to a 300-person global enterprise, will join WRAP as WRAP is working to transform its de-escalation doctrine and training platform into a scalable, recurring revenue business model