By Bill Cummings
Journal Inquirer, Manchester, Conn.
HARTFORD, Conn. — A former Hartford police officer charged with manslaughter in the fatal shooting of a man said to be suffering from a mental health crisis is claiming his arrest violated his constitutional right against self-incrimination.
An attorney for Joseph Magnano, who was arrested Feb. 27 for shooting 55-year-old Steven Jones multiple times as Jones walked toward officers holding a large knife, said in a motion that prosecutors wrongly based Magnano’s arrest on a written statement supervisors had ordered him to provide.
| DOWNLOAD: 5 officer safety conversations to have with your team
“He was answering for administrative purposes, under a superior officer’s order, without waiving his rights (against self-incrimination), and that he believed refusal would expose him to discipline or termination,” attorney Patrick Tomasiewicz wrote in a motion filed last week in Hartford Superior Court.
“The Fifth Amendment does not permit the government to obtain an employee’s account through constitutionally coercive employment pressure and then use that account, or evidence derived from it, to prosecute him,” Tomasiewicz wrote, adding the arrest warrant relied on substantial portions of the statement to justify Magnano’s prosecution.
The motion seeks a pretrial “Kastigar” hearing to determine whether the statement was compelled and whether prosecutors can proceed if those statements are ruled inadmissible. The motion also offers other remedies, including removal of portions of the evidence from the arrest warrant or disqualification of the state Office of Inspector General, which determined the shooting was not justified and now is prosecuting the case.
As of this week, the Office of Inspector General had not filed a formal response to the motion. The state Department of Criminal Justice did not respond to an email seeking comment on the motion.
In October, Magnano’s attorney sought dismissal of the case due to information not included in the warrant.
“Restored, the record describes the opposite of an officer who did not care whether Jones lived,” Tomasiewicz wrote in that motion. “In 26 seconds, Officer Magnano gave 14 commands, warned Jones twice that he would be shot, retreated approximately 40 feet, and placed himself between Jones and the public.”
Magnano was arrested earlier this year after a widely distributed video showed Jones walking down a Hartford street toward a group of officers, as some of those officers were attempting to talk to him. Body-camera footage showed Magnano arriving at the scene as three other officers were in the process of trying to calm Jones, who had used the knife to cut himself and was suicidal, according to a 911 call made by his sister.
While the other officers kept their distance from Jones and spoke to him softly, Magnano immediately began shouting at him to drop the knife. He then fired nine times at Jones, less than a minute after leaving his vehicle, according to reports at the time. Magnano, a probationary officer at the time of the shooting, was fired by the city on March 27.
The shooting drew widespread public outcry and questions over Hartford’s policies regarding people in mental distress.
In an arrest warrant issued May 17, the Connecticut Inspector General said an investigation found Magnano “did not engage in de-escalation measures (and) he failed to make reasonable attempts to use non-lethal force.”
The arrest warrant was criticized by members of the Hartford Police Union , who called it “factually inaccurate, intentionally deceptive and lacks critical exculpatory facts.”
In the motion filed last week, Tomasiewicz said that, following the shooting, Hartford police ordered Magnano “to give a thorough account of his use of deadly force. He complied and submitted his statement by the deadline his employer imposed.”
The arrest warrant, Tomasiewicz said, “reproduced his account across portions of two pages,” but omitted the Garrity warning in which Magnano said he was not waiving his rights regarding self-incrimination.
“The State presented the defendant’s signed statement,” the motion said. “It did not present the conditions under which the State obtained the explanation.”
Tomasiewicz predicted the state likely will argue the warrant’s defects do not justify dismissal of the charges.
“The warrant’s structure makes the connection clear,” the motion said.
“It articulates that Magnano described a protective barrier and a shrinking opportunity to retreat,’ the motion continued. “The affidavit proceeds to answer those explanations with findings that he failed to move civilians and had ample space. He described fear of grave injury, and yet the affidavit undermined whether that belief was reasonable.”
© 2026 Journal Inquirer, Manchester, Conn.. Visit www.journalinquirer.com.
Distributed by Tribune Content Agency, LLC.