Trending Topics

Wash. sheriff argues he is not a commissioned LEO in effort to continue receiving police pension payments

In a petition to continue receiving Seattle PD pension payments, Pierce County Sheriff Keith Swank has argued that that he does not meet the legal definition of an LEO

651760549_1260037779575120_2212181562014986461_n.png

Pierce County Sheriff’s Office/Facebook

By Peter Talbot
The Peninsula Gateway (Gig Harbor, Wash.)

PIERCE COUNTY, Wash. — Pierce County Sheriff Keith Swank is petitioning a judge to determine whether he is entitled to continue receiving his retirement pension from his service in the Seattle Police Department while Pierce County pays him for his work as sheriff.

Swank’s effort to get paid for his current job while also getting money from his retirement plan has forced him to take an unusual stance for his role as sheriff — that he does not meet the legal definition of law enforcement officer.

| DOWNLOAD: 5 officer safety conversations to have with your team

That’s because for Swank to get monthly payments from his retirement plan, the Law Enforcement Officers’ and Fire Fighters’ Plan II ( LEOFF II ), he has had to contend that he has not returned to work as a commissioned law enforcement officer since his June 2023 retirement from the Seattle Police Department.

In an August order, Laura Murphy, a presiding officer for the Department of Retirement Systems (DRS), rejected Swank’s assertion. Murphy found Swank was employed as a commissioned law enforcement officer and was not entitled to monthly pension payments.

A private attorney for Swank, Mark McCarty , filed a petition in September for judicial review. A hearing is scheduled for January before Pierce County Superior Court Judge Shelly K. Moss .

In response to questions, McCarty told The News Tribune in an email Tuesday that there is no requirement that a person be a commissioned law enforcement officer in Washington to be elected to and hold the office of county sheriff.

Efforts to reach Swank for comment were unsuccessful. Swank addressed reporting for this story in a Monday evening post on X. He said he considered it theft for Pierce County to take money out of his paycheck to put toward his retirement plan.

“If I had been elected to any other position in the state I would have been able to keep my pension, and other cops have done so,” Swank wrote.

Swank said his gross income in 2025 was $186,000, and his take-home pay each month was $1,000 more than his pension. He said the way he sees it, he’s working as sheriff for $12,000 per year. Swank noted police chiefs for cities such as Tacoma and Puyallup and sheriffs in other counties make more money than he does. He said being sheriff is a financial hardship because before he was elected he had a real estate business, and it has fallen on hard times because he doesn’t have time to do what is necessary.

If he wanted to make more money, Swank said, he would not be the sheriff. He said he could leverage his position and experience for “major money” working for a large public-safety corporation.

“I haven’t done it because I love my community, my county, my state, and my country,” Swank wrote. “I have been wearing a uniform for over 40 years defending our country and communities. So, when anyone says I have ulterior motives or don’t know what I am talking about, I take that with less than a grain of salt.”

Should Swank be allowed to pocket two government checks at the same time?

The practice is sometimes criticized by taxpayer activists as “double-dipping.” Swank’s salary as sheriff in 2026 is $200,770. It’s unclear how much money Seattle contributed to Swank’s retirement plan in his 33 years of service to its Police Department , or how much he was receiving each month after his retirement but before he became sheriff.

A spokesperson for the DRS told The News Tribune it would give Swank 10 business days to seek an injunction to prevent the department from releasing information it has determined is public.

Since becoming sheriff in January 2025 , Swank and Pierce County have continued to pay into his LEOFF II plan. According to court records filed in his petition for judicial review, Pierce County contributed $4,360.76 for the first five months of 2025. Those contributions would continue if a judge ultimately decides Swank has to stay enrolled in LEOFF II . Sheriff Swank claimed he resigned his commission

Swank’s position that he is not a commissioned law enforcement officer raises other questions. Under state law, the first duty of the sheriff is to uphold and enforce the Constitution and state laws. Does Swank believe he has the authority to make arrests or otherwise enforce the law?

In oral arguments, in March, Murphy asked McCarty whether a person has to be a commissioned law enforcement officer to carry a firearm in their capacity as a deputy sheriff or sheriff. McCarty wasn’t sure, but he said his experience is that if you’re a law enforcement officer, you’ve got to carry a weapon.

“And so is it Mr. Swank’s position that he does not carry a firearm or a sidearm if he’s in uniform?” Murphy asked, according to a transcript of the hearing. McCarty said he hadn’t asked Swank that question.

“I don’t know the answer to that,” McCarty said. “But I’ve known Mr. Swank for a long time, and he’s always carried a weapon as far as when I’ve been with him.”

Murphy’s order also noted Swank apparently said he resigned his commission on May 12, 2025 . That was part of his argument regarding why he no longer met the definition of law enforcement officer.

A prior decision by the DRS found Swank had to be enrolled in the LEOFF II plan. The decision cited a statement from McCarty indicating that Swank had notified the state Criminal Justice Training Commission that he had resigned his commission. McCarty said that removed him from membership in the retirement plan without affecting his ability to serve as sheriff.

In pleadings submitted ahead of Murphy’s decision, an attorney for the DRS, Bridget McBryde , wrote Swank was arguably conflating the qualifications and requirements for sheriff with what it legally means to be county sheriff. She said Swank hadn’t addressed the fact that once a person becomes sheriff, state and local law empowers them to enforce criminal laws regardless of having a certification from the CJTC or prior experience in law enforcement.

“Mr. Swank is a certified officer,” McBryde wrote. “Resigning a commission, in the case of the sheriff, is resigning his office.”

McBryde said Swank did not appear to be offering to resign as sheriff to return to retirement.

The News Tribune asked the CJTC if it had a record of Swank notifying it that he was resigning his commission. David Quinlan , a spokesperson for the CJTC, said Monday it could not locate a formal, written notice from Swank stating he was resigning his Pierce County commission. ‘An incredibly unique set of circumstances’

In his oral arguments before Murphy, McCarty laid out Swank’s position. According to a transcript of the hearing, McCarty said the position of DRS is that it gets to decide what “commissioned” means when it comes to the retirement system. He said DRS wanted to ignore “the whole legislative body” for how someone is certified and commissioned.

“I think Mr. Swank presents an incredibly unique set of circumstances that I don’t think anybody could have — could have thought of as happening,” McCarty said, according to the transcript.

McCarty argued state law, RCW 41.26.030, defines a law enforcement officer as a person who is commissioned and employed to enforce the law.

Being commissioned is different from being certified. To work as a police officer in Seattle , Swank had to be certified by the CJTC, the state entity that trains, certifies and can decertify officers. Swank worked for the Seattle Police Department from 1990 to 2023, when he retired at the rank of captain.

A commission is the authority granted by an appointing law enforcement agency to act as an officer on its behalf, according to Quinlan of the CJTC. Generally, an officer’s commission with an agency ends when they separate from it, including through retirement.

In Washington , the qualifications required to be sheriff are minimal, but state law does require sheriffs to obtain certification from the CJTC within 12 months of assuming office. Although Gov. Bob Ferguson signed a bill into law on April 1 setting stricter qualifications, a Superior Court judge permanently blocked parts of it from being implemented (the Washington Attorney General’s Office said it would appeal).

After Swank retired from Seattle PD, he began collecting his pension. In November 2024 , Pierce County voters elected him sheriff, and he became sheriff on Jan. 1, 2025 . McCarty told Murphy when Swank was sworn in, he took the same oath taken by every other elected official in Pierce County .

“And when he’s not commissioned, he has to do something affirmatively to become commissioned again or to become certified to become commissioned,” McCarty said. “He’s done nothing.”

McBryde said in oral arguments that Swank was using a narrow definition of commissioned law enforcement officer. She told Murphy that the state law McCarty cited to define a law enforcement officer, RCW 41.26.030, does not define “commissioned.”

McBryde said the DRS, as a state agency assigned to administer legislation regarding retirement plans, has authority to interpret legislation. She said the DRS has defined “commissioned” for retirement-plan purposes to mean someone employed as an officer of a general authority Washington law enforcement agency who is empowered to enforce the state’s criminal laws.

“Mr. Swank clearly meets this definition,” McBryde said. “He is employed as an officer of a general authority Washington law enforcement agency, and he is empowered to enforce the criminal laws of the state of Washington.”

Swank also has to be considered employed to be a law enforcement officer, and McCarty argued Swank is not a Pierce County employee. Pierce County Code 3.20.020 states that elected officials are not considered county employees.

McBryde said the DRS is not bound by how Pierce County defines Swank. She said the DRS is instead bound to follow state legislation, and its interpretation is the state Legislature intended elected sheriffs to be members of the LEOFF II plan.

Trending
“Investing in this technology allows us to be more proactive in addressing challenges and finding solutions to better serve our community,” Pullman PD Chief Aaron Breshears said
Southside ISD Police Officer Christina Lozano, 47, was described as a “dedicated and valued employee,” as well as a “loving mother and grandmother”
The suspect was tracked down and arrested after appearing to deliberately drive toward and hit an officer, according to the Medway Police Department
The man walked forward as the Metro Nashville Police detective backed away, approaching within feet of him before officers fired the fatal shots

© 2026 The Peninsula Gateway (Gig Harbor, Wash.). Visit www.thenewstribune.com.
Distributed by Tribune Content Agency, LLC.

Company News
Marine Corps veteran and former Babel Street Chief Operating Officer, who helped build a national security technology company from early-stage startup to a 300-person global enterprise, will join WRAP as WRAP is working to transform its de-escalation doctrine and training platform into a scalable, recurring revenue business model