By Lucas Daprile
Cleveland.com Express Desk
cleveland.com
CLEVELAND, Ohio – A Cleveland woman whose daughter was fleeing a gunman when police opened fire on her moving car in 2024 can move forward with a lawsuit against the two officers who fired the shots, a state appeals court has ruled.
The 8th District Court of Appeals on Thursday reversed a lower court’s decision to dismiss a lawsuit filed by Latrice Carter against Cleveland police officers Dylan O’Donnell and Amanda Rock.
| DOWNLOAD: 5 officer safety conversations to have with your team
The case stems from a March 17, 2024, incident in which Carter’s daughter, Antwonia Carter, was driving near East 105th Street and Garfield Avenue when a gunman leaned out of a window and opened fire on her car.
Antwonia fled the scene and drove past her mother’s house, where police had already been dispatched. As she passed the house, officers O’Donnell and Rock fired at her moving car.
Antwonia Carter, 26, died in the shooting, but authorities determined that she was killed by Christopher Stinson, who was riding in the vehicle chasing her, not by the police officers who also fired at her car. Prosecutors say Stinson fired at least 20 shots at Carter’s vehicle. He was later sentenced to prison.
Carter’s lawsuit accuses the two officers of negligent infliction of emotional distress, saying she suffered severe trauma after watching them fire at her daughter’s car. The lawsuit does not claim that the officers’ gunfire injured or killed her daughter.
The incident unfolded after Cleveland officers responded to the Garfield Avenue home of Carter’s mother. Gunfire erupted nearby while the officers were speaking with Latrice Carter, and Antwoina Carter’s vehicle came down the street toward them while being fired upon from the pursuing car.
Believing the gunfire was coming from Carter’s vehicle, O’Donnell and Rock opened fire on it, according to the city’s motion seeking dismissal of the lawsuit.
Latrice Carter told the officers they were shooting at her daughter before the daughter crashed her car.
Cleveland Safety Director Wayne Drummond said at the time that the officers were in a “stressful, chaotic and dangerous” situation and feared for their lives, but an investigation found they failed to verify a visible and immediate threat before firing.
O’Donnell and Rock were subsequently disciplined for violating the Cleveland Division of Police’s use-of-deadly-force policy. O’Donnell was suspended for 15 days and Rock for 10 days. O’Donnell resigned from Cleveland police in August while in good standing. He is employed full-time as an officer with Bentleyville Police Department . Rock remains employed by Cleveland police, according to the Ohio Attorney General’s online police database.
The lawsuit, filed in July 2025 , contends that the officers’ conduct caused Latrice Carter emotional distress, trauma and post-traumatic stress disorder despite the fact that another shooter was responsible for her daughter’s death.
City of Cleveland spokesman Tyler Sinclair noted none of the shots fired by officer struck Antwonia Carter.
“This was a stressful, chaotic, and dangerous situation and it was only at that point – when they were under extreme pressure and in fear for their lives – did they discharge their service weapons,” Sinclair said in a statement.
Attorneys representing the officers successfully asked Cuyahoga County Common Pleas Judge Kelly Gallagher to dismiss the case, arguing that employees of political subdivisions are generally immune from negligence claims under Ohio law.
The appeals court concluded that dismissing the case at that stage was premature.
Writing for the three-judge panel, Judge Sean Gallagher said Carter’s complaint went beyond accusations of ordinary negligence and contained sufficient claims of reckless conduct to survive a motion to dismiss. Under Ohio law, government employees generally have immunity, but that protection can be lost when their actions are wanton or reckless.
“This is not a case involving allegations of mere negligence,” Gallagher wrote.
The ruling does not decide whether O’Donnell or Rock acted recklessly. Instead, the appeals court found that Carter’s complaint contained sufficient claims of reckless conduct to survive the officers’ motion to dismiss, allowing the case to proceed.
Judges Lisa Forbes and Mary Boyle concurred in the decision.
The appellate ruling sends Carter’s case back to Cuyahoga County Common Pleas Court.
It’s unclear if Cleveland plans to appeal the decision.
©2026 Advance Local Media LLC. Visit cleveland.com. Distributed by Tribune Content Agency, LLC.