Trending Topics

D.C. officers reinstated after receiving pardon from Trump in 2020 pursuit death

Officer Terence Sutton, previously convicted of second-degree murder and reckless driving, has been reinstated but will not return to patrol immediately; Lt. Andrew Zabavsky was also reinstated

WASHINGTON — The D.C. Police Department has reinstated two officers who received presidential pardons after being convicted in connection with the 2020 death of Karon Hylton-Brown, who crashed while fleeing police on a moped, WUSA reported.

Officer Terence Sutton and Lt. Andrew Zabavsky were granted full pardons by President Donald Trump in January. Sutton, previously sentenced to five years in prison for second-degree murder and reckless driving, has been reinstated but will not return to patrol duties immediately, according to the report. Zabavsky was also reinstated this week.

Sutton pursued Hylton-Brown for riding a moped on the sidewalk without a helmet; in doing so, he violated D.C. police policy, which prohibits pursuits for minor traffic infractions, according to the report.

Prosecutors argued that Sutton acted recklessly and that he and Zabavsky tried to cover up details of the incident. Sutton’s defense maintained that Hylton-Brown had been flagged earlier in the day for suspicious behavior and that officers believed he was armed and dangerous.

In January, Trump issued pardons for both officers, stating that they had been unfairly prosecuted. The pardons effectively dismissed their convictions, as their appeals were still pending at the time, according to the report.

Trending
“If you take away [officers’] discretion by mandating quotas ... it doesn’t bode well for police-community relationships,” former sheriff and State Rep. Phil Plummer said
The Pennsylvania State Police officers pursued a group suspected in a sporting goods store theft; after the pursuit, one suspect began firing shots from inside the vehicle
“It has been an honor to serve the Oakland community, and I am grateful for the support I’ve received from the residents,” said Chief Floyd Mitchell, who was appointed in May 2024
“There is no path to advancement, no vision for the future, no investment in the people who risk their lives every single day,” Former Moss Point PD Chief Brandon Ashley said

Joanna Putman is an Associate Editor and newswriter at Police1, where she has been covering law enforcement topics since August 2023. Based in Orlando, Florida, she holds a journalism degree from the University of Florida and spent two years working in nonprofit local newsrooms, gaining experience in community-focused reporting. Married to a law enforcement officer, she works hard to highlight the challenges and triumphs of those who serve and protect. Have a news tip? Email her at news@lexipol.com