You’re sitting across from a confidential informant who just dropped a name. A suspected member of a drug trafficking organization. The location of a possible murder weapon. Maybe even the location of a stash house. It’s solid intel — at least, it feels that way. But it’s just one source. One version of the truth. And one version should not be good enough.
In law enforcement, human intelligence (HUMINT) is often the spark that lights an investigation. It’s raw, fast and sometimes the only lead available. But it’s also inherently flawed. People lie. They misremember. They exaggerate. And sometimes, they simply want to get out of jail or get cash. That’s why good investigators should not stop at what they’re told — they test it. They challenge it. They verify it. And today, one of the most powerful tools for that verification is open-source intelligence (OSINT).
Used together, HUMINT and OSINT form a feedback loop. HUMINT provides the tip. OSINT tests the tip, or vice versa. If both align, the case gains momentum. If they diverge, it forces a closer look. In either scenario, investigators stay grounded in facts — not assumptions.
| RELATED: Thinking like a criminal: How OSINT can take your investigations further
How HUMINT adds context to criminal investigations
HUMINT offers context no database can. A seasoned CI can tell you who’s feuding with who, who just got out of prison, and who changed cars last week. They’ll know the nickname that never shows up in TLO, the burner phone used only for late-night pickups, or the shift in gang leadership no agency memo has documented yet.
But they’re also human — meaning the intel comes bundled with bias, misunderstanding, and sometimes ulterior motives.
Using OSINT to corroborate or challenge HUMINT
That’s where OSINT comes in. A CI says a suspect drives a black Charger. You check parking lot security footage from a nearby gas station and spot a black Dodge — license plate partially visible. You run Facebook and see the suspect tagged in a photo standing next to the same car. A neighbor on Nextdoor mentions “a sketchy guy with a black sports car” showing up late at night. You check and verify that same car parked in the background of a geotagged Instagram or Snapchat post. All of these independent points, all lining up.
That’s the power of OSINT. It lets you corroborate HUMINT without tipping your hand. You don’t need a knock-and-talk to verify a suspect’s online persona. You don’t need a subpoena to browse public Venmo or PayPal payments that hint at drug transactions. You can use Zillow to verify the layout of an address a CI described, Google Earth to see the street view, and the Wayback Machine to recover a social media post the suspect deleted.
A CI says a stolen item was posted for sale — now it’s gone. You pull the cache or archived version of the listing and screenshot it for your file. You search OfferUp, Letgo, Facebook Marketplace, and Craigslist to cross-check dates and account names. The more angles you check, the less you’re guessing.
You can run usernames through Have I Been Pwned to find old email ties, and this is all before ever needing TLO. Plug license plates into public ALPR scan sites or car spotting forums. Cross-reference tattoos described by your source against photos on Instagram, Snapchat, or TikTok. Use advanced Google operators like “site:reddit.com + suspect name” to find overlooked threads or digital footprints. And never underestimate what shows up in local Facebook groups — especially those centered around gossip, HOA alerts, or scanner traffic.
But the process also works in reverse. Sometimes, OSINT disproves what you’re told. A CI says the suspect was at a house party Thursday night. Snapchat stories and tagged Instagram posts show the suspect working late at a local bar. Geotagged photos and digital timestamps don’t lie. When that happens, the goal isn’t to discredit — it’s to calibrate. Informants who know you verify what they say tend to offer better information over time.
Why HUMINT and OSINT together build stronger cases
Like any tool, HUMINT has its place — but its strength comes from being tested. And OSINT, for all its reach, still can’t replace the human pulse of a community member who knows where to look and who to watch. It’s the interplay that matters: real-world observation backed by digital verification.
The best investigators don’t just gather intelligence — they test it. Two truths, pulled from two different worlds, build a stronger foundation than either source could alone.
Because in this line of work, you don’t bet your case on what one person says. You bet it on what you can prove — twice.
| NEXT: Social media as an investigative tool: OSINT strategies for law enforcement
