Trending Topics

Are 12-hour patrol shifts the best? Police1 readers weigh in

Police1 readers say longer shifts can improve work-life balance, but staffing shortages, overtime and rotating schedules often determine whether the benefits last

0fb7f4be-dd33-41c1-b11a-e83cfae84301.png

Image created via chatGPT

When the Hoover Police Department announced it was moving patrol officers from 8-hour shifts to 12-hour shifts, department leaders said the change was intended to improve officer wellness and work-life balance.

Under the new schedule, every patrol officer will have every other Friday, Saturday and Sunday off. The change gives newer officers regular weekends away from work, an option that previously depended largely on seniority.

The move prompted Police1 readers to share their own experiences working 8-, 10- and 12-hour schedules. Some said the longer shifts gave them more time with family and a better opportunity to reset. Others warned that a scheduled 12-hour day can easily stretch to 16 hours because of late arrests, reports, court appearances or mandatory overtime.

| RELATED: 1,000 cops talk about shift schedules — and what’s not working

Across the responses, one point stood out: Whether a 12-hour schedule supports officer wellness often depends on how the schedule is structured, how well the agency is staffed and whether officers rotate between days and nights.

Here is what Police1 readers had to say.

More days off can mean more time to reset

Supporters of 12-hour shifts said the biggest benefit is having more full days away from work, including every other weekend under schedules like the one adopted in Hoover.

“Without a doubt, 12-hour shifts are the way to go. In my career, we’ve worked 8-hour shifts and 10-hour shifts. The 12-hour shifts give the officer every other weekend off and promote more stability in their lives, giving them more family time together and more days off. It’s most definitely a win/ win situation for everyone!”

Another reader said the change had a noticeable effect on life away from the job.

“I went from a department that was on an 8-hour schedule to a department with a 12-hour schedule. I’m truly happier with the 12-hour schedule. More time away from work is a great reset.”

For some, the schedule also makes it easier to take longer stretches of leave or pick up extra work.

“Yes, I do. The schedule mentioned is called the Pittman schedule. It gives EVERYONE a fair chance to have weekends off, instead of just senior officers. This schedule is used by a vast majority of agencies in South Carolina. It is extremely popular. One benefit is that an officer needs only use two days of vacation or comp time to have a full week off. Sick leave goes down, and officers get more rest. They also have more time available to work extra jobs, increasing their income. I don’t think there are many agencies that discard this system once they try it!”

When 12 hours becomes 16

Other readers said the benefits can disappear when a long patrol shift is followed by a late call, unfinished reports, court or additional assignments.

“I think if 12-hour shifts really mean 12-hour shifts, there is value in implementing them — both to benefit officers and agencies. I believe they work in agencies that rarely require overtime, and that limit off-duty judicial appearances. Otherwise, I think they are problematic for both officers and for agencies.”

One reader who had worked both schedules said 8-hour days left more usable time on workdays, while the first day off after a run of 12-hour shifts often became a recovery day.

“I have worked 8-hour shifts and 12-hour shifts. For my specific case, no, I do not think the 12-hour shift improves wellness. I was fortunate to land a position at our PD that is on a M-F 8-hour schedule, and I much prefer that. 12-hour shifts are like working a day-and-a-half every workday, and that’s before you get stuck with a late call, or a ton of paper at the end of the shift. 8-hour days still give me time to do something else every day when I get finished with my shift. On 12-hour days, I only wanted to workout, eat, sleep, get up and do it all over again. It was harder to fit family time in. The days off during the week were nice, but day #1 was usually a recovery day (especially after working 36 hours every other weekend). I guess I prefer fewer hours per day — more days per week. That allows me to balance work/family time better.”

Staffing also shaped how readers viewed the schedule. One officer said the promised benefits did not materialize at an understaffed department, particularly for night-shift officers expected to attend court during the day.

“Hasn’t worked for my department. Staffing is still short, which admin said would be fixed by going to 12 hours. Saying more officers would be on the patrol shifts. The 7-to-7 hours aren’t helpful when dealing with night officers going to court. Court isn’t required to work with the PD schedule, so officers are getting morning and afternoon court. Ergo, officers are not getting enough sleep before coming into work. Also, if working night shift, the officer is actually working 7 hours into their first day off. So their first day of is actually only a half day and they probably need to sleep for a section of it. So much for ‘officer wellness.’ The department had transitioned from a 6 on, 3 off schedule (8-hour days).”

Fixed shifts versus rotating days and nights

Several readers said the length of the workday was only part of the equation. Moving repeatedly between day and night shifts, they said, can make it difficult to establish a consistent sleep schedule.

“I’ve worked both 8-hour patrol shifts and 12-hour patrol shifts after my department switched to them. Eight-hour shifts, in my opinion, are much better for officer well-being. While the amount of days off are nice with 12-hour shifts, the rotating between nights and days is miserable. Twelve hours is also too long of a day on patrol and allows for very little personal time on work days. Eight-hour shifts allowed me more time with my family even on work days, including midnight shifts, as ours didn’t start until 10:30 p.m. If a department is worried about the younger officer having weekends off, give a set days-off rotation for officers to go on and let seniority decide which shift they prefer. Otherwise, as my department has always stated, “put in your time” if you want the weekends off.”

Another veteran officer said the regular three-day weekends were valuable, but the physical and mental demands outweighed that benefit over time.

“I have worked 36 years in law enforcement and have experience working 8, 10 and 12-hour shifts. My last five years have been on the 12-hour shift model rotating every 8 weeks between days and nights. It is beneficial to be off every other Friday through Sunday. However, the 12-hour shift is physically and mentally grueling, even with the three-day weekend twice per month. The 8- and 10-hour shifts provided for less total days off but better rest and sleep as a whole. The on-duty days are very difficult as one gets little sleep, especially if you add in training, court etc. 12-hour shifts would be more tolerable on a fixed shift model and not rotating. The 12-hour shift just isn’t a long-term benefit in terms of rest, health, and preparedness for duty. Another important consideration is to ensure adequate leave is available to officers and a suitable number of officers are working every shift. I worked for a department that was always short-staffed. Answering every call on a busy summer weekend for 12 hours isn’t sustainable. All in all I feel the 8-hour shift is still the best all around.”

Facebook readers weigh the tradeoffs

Police1 readers on Facebook echoed many of the same themes, with several saying a fixed assignment may matter more than whether a shift lasts eight, 10 or 12 hours.

“The length of shift is not as important as staying on a shift. Switching back and forth between nights and days doesn’t allow your body to get used to a sleep schedule”

Others said their agencies had used 12-hour schedules successfully for years, particularly when the rotation included every other weekend off.

“When our department went to 12 hours, most officers really liked them. The system we went to an officer had every other weekend off. Great incentive for newer officers. That was about 12 years ago. Most officers still like them. Never going to satisfy everyone.”

“Worked many different shifts in the last 20+ years. The 12-hour shift with every other Friday-Sunday off is great. Permanent days and nights seem to fit well with those that like it; the month of days and month of nights were tough. But overall, the rotation gives great work-life balance; if you take away special assignments, court and any extra duties you volunteer for.”

Long shifts paired with mandatory overtime remained a concern, especially for officers at understaffed agencies.

“I have worked 41 continuous years in LE. I retired as a cop with 34 years of service in 2019. I have worked as a deputy sheriff for over seven years. I have worked many different patrol shifts. The PD I retired from was terribly understaffed. Officers being held over after shift was a common practice. I have worked all combinations of shifts. I prefer 10-hour shifts. 12 hours are challenging when being held over on OT.”

Another reader said factors such as age, commute and workload should be considered before an agency settles on a single model.

“I’ve worked eights, tens and twelves. A lot of it has to do with the officers’ age, distance from home, volume of work and other factors. Keep in mind, a 12-hour shift can turn into 16-hours with a late arrest, court the next day and additional ‘assignments.’ A combination of the three shifts works out best so a city or county always has coverage.”

For one reader, however, the additional time away from work made the schedule an easy choice.

“Great schedule, I worked nights 4 days on 4 days off. You will use less sick time, comp, holiday comp, and vacation. Plenty of time for off-duty details and family.”

The responses show why shift changes can be difficult to evaluate through the number of scheduled hours alone. A 12-hour model can offer predictable weekends and more full days off, but its effect on wellness may depend on whether shifts are fixed, overtime is controlled, court schedules are considered and enough officers are available to cover calls.

Do 12-hour patrol shifts improve officer wellness?



Police1 readers respond:

  • In my department, we have been working 24-hour shifts for over a year now. We are allowed 6 hours of rest during the shift. At first, it was nice to work only two shifts a week and get guaranteed 8 hours of overtime each week after only 2 shifts. It was started as a way to fill staffing shortages. It has become VERY difficult and is definitely unhealthy. We are working on a new schedule. At this point, I would be happy going to 5 eight-hour shifts.
  • I worked a 6 on, 2 off 8-hour day schedule for the first 9 years of my career on late watch. This schedule gave you back-to-back 3-day weekends off every 6 weeks. That schedule was horrible. I worked the next 7 years on a 12-hour schedule and loved it. The long shifts could become burdensome, but the added off days allowed for better work/ life balance. I prefer the 12s, but you’re not going to please everyone. Our department had a mass exodus from retirements, and going to 12s kept most patrol divisions at the same number of officers on the street that we had on 8s prior to the mass exodus.
  • I’ve worked 8s and 12s. I started with 12s at my first department, a larger suburban department, and really liked them. I was rarely called in for overtime (which I didn’t like I’m kind of an overtime hound). Having every other weekend off was great and the short week if I wanted to take time off. Then when I went to a small rural sheriff’s department, I worked 8s. We always seemed short and I worked a lot of OT but you would get weekends off about every 2 years for 4 months when your rotation came. When I became Undersheriff, I actually would have deputies coming to me asking me not to give them weekends off. I thought they were hard chargers. No, they told me if I gave them weekends, they would end up getting ordered in because everyone always takes weekends off if they are going to take time off. Now they are on 12s, and it has gotten better but there is still a lot of OT. When they complain about having to work OT, I explain that they need to work together, and maybe it’s easier to trade a day instead of taking time off. We have been working on increasing road patrol, but I can only do so much with the $$ that is available.
  • I have been a law enforcement officer for 46 years this year. My son is also in Law Enforcement and is the wellness officer for his department. We have talked several times about 12-hour shifts and the effects they have on officers. The question I have asked is: when 12-hour shifts turn into 16-hour shifts, how alert is an officer? How many days in a row can an officer work 16-hour shifts and not get burnout? Also, most of the officers who want 12-hour shifts only look at more days off and not the trade off of what they are giving up in other areas. When they get older and near retirement age those 12 or 16-hour shifts will catch up to them at a cost.
  • In our department, we work 12 hrs., 10 hrs., and 8 hrs. The shifts are selected by seniority, and the other benefit is that the 12 hrs., and 10 hrs. get differential pay of 13% additional. Yes, for me it works and improves officer wellness and work life balance.
  • I personally prefer the 12-hour shifts because it allows me every other weekend off; but it’s also a 3-day weekend! I feel more rejuvenated than if I worked M-F, 8-hour days. I didn’t like working 5 days, then having only 2 days off to reset.
  • Without a doubt, 12-hour shifts are the to go. In my career, we’ve worked 8-hour shifts and 10-hour shifts. The 12-hour shifts give the Officer every other weekend off and promote more stability in their lives, giving them more family time together and more days off. It’s most definitely a win/ win situation for everyone!
  • What is not mentioned in this article is the fact that a 12 hr work day only accounts for the hours at work. If an officer lives 30 mins to an hour away from work, which is not uncommon in large city departments, that adds to the day. Add in 15 mins at the beginning and end of shift for donning/doffing uniforms and equipment. On a work day, these officers are putting in 15-16 hr days. Now figure in sleep, studies show we truly need 8 hrs a day for health and wellness. So we are now at 23-24 hrs with zero personal or family time during the work week. Never mind that none of us get that, this is supposed to be about wellness and that’s what we are supposed to be getting. That is without being held over for a late call, arrest or paperwork. As mentioned, the first day off is half wasted with recovery on the front end. The benefit just isn’t there. Departments are hiding behind the term “wellness” to justify implementing shift lengths in order to ,at least what they believe, achieve full patrol coverage with less officers.
  • It truly depends. Initially and after a few years, they seem to work great. But a lengthy patrol career will result in late calls, arrests resulting in transports to county jail, having to stay late to write the in-custody report, court appearances, and commute times that will wear on you in the longer term. The 12-hour shifts initially were nice to have that extra day off every two weeks, however, after a while, it reversed. I NEEDED the extra day off BECAUSE of the 12’s.
  • I like 12hr shifts but not every other week rotation
  • 12-hour shifts are a temporary bandage for the administration to cover shifts due to the lack of manpower. You will never get that manpower back; 12-hour shifts turned into 14, 16 power shifts. Your three days off don’t outweigh the laborious extended shifts. At that point you are a warm body, not mentally stable and ready to give your best. You are mentally weak. This has great potential to cause officers to make poor judgment discussions when they are fatigued leading to use of force mistakes!! Which is the hottest topic in law enforcement today. Excessive use of force.
  • So many things not considered., rotating shifts, natural circadian rhythm, just enough time to get off, shower, sleep shower and back, commute time, family, 10 is about the limit. Having worked 24, 12, 10 & 8, 12 was the worst. then factor the last call stretching out, OT, emergency hold over. Mental fog after a full shift and the need to make quick critical decisions. Then you have court dates, short staff, command not knowing what patrol work is like. Morale begins to suffer.
  • I think 12-hour shifts can be a great thing, especially if staffed properly. If not staffed properly, it is going to be a long 12+ hour day. The way my department created the 12s actually increased the amount of officers on the streets, but with poor retention, it has now created something where we run minimum or below almost every day. Getting people to sign up for an additional 12 hours is like pulling teeth.

Trending
Ann Arbor’s A2 REACH program will operate 11 a.m. to 7 p.m. Monday through Friday, with 911 dispatchers assessing calls and deploying the best response
The expanded state program offers forgivable loans and reduced mortgage rates to help recruit and retain first responders in the communities they serve
A man walked past Jacksonville Sheriff’s officers, ignoring their commands to stop and take his hand out of his pocket after they heard a series of gunshots being fired
An attorney representing a former Hartford Police officer Joseph Magnano stated that a job-required statement was used to charge him in the fatal shooting of Steven Jones

Company News
Marine Corps veteran and former Babel Street Chief Operating Officer, who helped build a national security technology company from early-stage startup to a 300-person global enterprise, will join WRAP as WRAP is working to transform its de-escalation doctrine and training platform into a scalable, recurring revenue business model

Sarah Roebuck is the senior news editor for Police1, Corrections1, FireRescue1 and EMS1, leading daily news coverage. With over a decade of digital journalism experience, she has been recognized for her expertise in digital media, including being sourced in Broadcast News in the Digital Age.

A graduate of Central Michigan University with a broadcast and cinematic arts degree, Roebuck joined Lexipol in April 2023. Have a news tip? Email her at sroebuck@lexipol.com or connect on LinkedIn.